grumpy
Since the introduction of Zero last weekend, quite a few bloggers have gotten their shorts in a knot over the license that governs the use of Zero software. Given the huge swell of support there has been for open source software in recent years, some disappointment was expected; after all, IBM has contributed to a number of open source projects, and no other community is more open and free-spirited than the one focused on REST and RIA. It seems like the perfect match!
Despite this disappointment, I still find the jaded dismissal of the project by popular geek bloggers to be a bit over-the-top. Most of their dismissals are based on cursory inspection of the web site and the fairly narrow-minded assumption that because open source projects have become popular in the last three or four years, that thirty years of industry behavior is now irrelevant and no one except for Microsoft will sell a proprietary software platform ever again. For a group that is usually excited to see new technologies sprout up in the areas of REST and RIA, there's an awful lot of grumpiness surrounding this arrival. It reminds me of the Grumpy Old Man character that Dana Carvey used to portray on SNL's Weekend Update:
In my day, we didn't use software written by big companies. If you wanted to run a program that belonged to a big company, you just re-wrote it! In K&R C! And then you printed out the code and mailed it to the company employees, and you laughed at them, and said "Look at me, I re-wrote your program in one day and it's eight times faster and cures baldness! You're all worthless programmers!" And then you threw the code away, just to spite them! And if you ever had to run the program again, you just said "Flobble-dee-flee!" and you re-wrote it. And that's the way it was, and we liked it! We loved it!It's been almost a week since those first rants started to roll in, and so far I have held back on my desire to fire back; at this point, I feel that I can safely ignore them and focus on more postive things surrounding Zero. Regarding future discussions, I welcome debate on the merits of IBM's decision to keep Zero proprietary and its ultimate effect on the success of the project, but I hope that future blog posts will be a little more thorough in their research and commentary. And less grumpy.
Labels: narcissism, zero
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home